BBW Porn Battle: Plumper Pass vs. XL Girls

We really like big, curvy girls. So yea, we are pretty much blowing through our BBW-based content early. Hell, if we thought it would be feasible for an entire year, BBW porn would be the only thing we discuss and post on this blog.

But it isn’t. Not if we want to go beyond just posting pictures and videos and actually writing. We should probably be pacing ourselves.

As said in our post about BBW porn, there are only a few high quality BBW pay sites. And by “few” we mean three. And by “three” we mean we should really reduce things to two because a couple of sites fall far above the rest of the totem pole.

It doesn’t get any better than Plumper Pass and XL Girls when it comes to watching BBW content. They are the clear-cut top two BBW porn sites right now. At the rate they are working, it will probably stay that way for some time.

Plumper Pass focuses on hardcore action featuring some of the best BBW pornstars today. They take pride in showcasing “true” BBWs and delivering on reality-esque porn. XL Girls introduces new faces to the genre while presenting more well-known girls in fresh environments.

Normally we would just tell you to spend your money on both sites and let your weiner have a field day, or week, or month. They are both so different in style and look that you really can’t choose one over the other. But that’s not how Pornucate works.

If your porn dollars can only go to one site, we’ll give our thoughts on which one gives BBW lovers (and general porn lovers alike) the most bang for their buck. It’s the battle between the site featuring “all plump, all natural, and all stacked” models, and the site boasting the best hardcore action in BBW and plumper porn.

Model Collection

Plumper Pass tends to cycle through the same pool of models for their content. Which is fine. We have to keep in mind that BBW is still niche porn, so it’s not like their library of girls is vast like in more generalized porn.

If anything, the selection Plumper Pass chooses from is a great one. All of the big names (no pun intended) you would expect are getting in on the action. In the past month alone we have seen updates from Sashaa Juggs, Lila Lovely, and Lexxxi Luxe.

Plumper Pass will introduce a new girl every now and again, one of the more recent being Nirvana Lust. But on a whole, it’s the girls we know and search for. There are some points where it feels like we are watching the same content repeatedly.

XL Girls has a larger selection, mostly due to Score’s penchant for finding new girls and producing a blast of content for them. The site has a lot of girls you won’t see anywhere else, like Allie Pearson, Nila Mason, and Renee Ross. That’s great because it creates the feeling of discovering someone new and fresh every other week.

But the biggest thing is that XL Girls covers a wider range of body types. There’s a reason we said Plumper Pass tends to show more “true” BBWs. XL Girls blurs the lines between what is considered BBW, plumper, and just voluptuous.

It’s the bridge for porn viewers who really aren’t into fat porn, but want to at least look at girls who are thick and curvy. It’s a little more inclusive. I’m sure the site probably gets some criticism for not always being true to the body type, but I figure the more eyes on the niche, the better.

Advantage: XL Girls

Interface/Navigation

veronica vaughn plumper pass
Veronica Vaughn, BBW pornstar on Plumper Pass.

This section won’t take long because XL Girls’ navigational features are lacking. The site uses tags to describe their content, but its use of these tags is quite generous. For example, there are a lot of models given the “big ass” tag when all they really have is a big butt by default of being a big girl. There’s no nuance.

Plumper Pass has different categories that accurately describe their models. If you like BBWs with big boobs, the site will give you girls with the biggest. Along with suggesting models similar to ones you look at, it is easier to find the type of girl you really like.

There isn’t much difference between the two interfaces. Both sites open up by showing you their latest updates and top models. The only difference is that XL Girls separates their photo and video content (because not all photo galleries have a matching video, and vice-versa).

Advantage: Plumper Pass

Content Variety

An easy win for XL Girls. What’s amazing is the site wins for the simplest of reasons: it has solo content. That’s really all this boils down to.

Plumper Pass has plenty of hardcore action to offer. Sometimes with one girl, at times two girls and one guy (lucky bastard), others two guys and one girl. But one thing they continue to lack is solo content of their girls.

This is probably a bigger deal now than it would have been years ago. Years ago, no guy would ever bring up the idea of not wanting to see another dude’s dick in a video, or wanting softer content. And yet, as we grow more aware of what repeated exposure of porn can do to our brains, these are the kind of discussions we are having.

Some guys want their videos to only contain women. Plumper Pass cannot offer that. XL Girls can while also offering hardcore action. Plumper Pass offers the same rinse, wash, repeat process for their videos. XL Girls tries to throw girls into different environments. Easy win.

Advantage: XL Girls

Content Quality

This would have been another easy win for XL Girls. That was until Plumper Pass began offering 1080p video quality. That completely changed the game for BBW content.

XL Girls has great picture quality, which is really the result of being produced by the Score team. Offering high quality pictures is their bread and butter. The videos are still nice at 720p, but we cannot help but feel it can be even better. If Score’s site Pornmegaload can have 1080p quality videos, why can’t XL Girls?

Plumper Pass is stepping up in the picture quality and the effort is appreciated. Considering their galleries have hundreds of pictures, it is nice to see all the still action in larger formats. But creating 1080p quality videos was a real difference-maker for the site.

Only the biggest and best porn sites invest in great video quality, and it is rarely seen in niche porn. Plumper Pass really separated itself in this regard. Plus, the videos offer great action. While it may not offer much in the solo department, some XL Girls videos can be listless and drawn-out.

In choosing between picture quality and video quality, video is king. Plus, it’s not like the pictures on XL Girls are WAY above the quality of Plumper Pass photos. It’s not like XL Girls is the BBW equivalent of Hegre-Art.

Hmm, maybe someone should create the BBW equivalent of Hegre-Art.

Advantage: Plumper Pass

Update Frequency

Plumper Pass does an update every three days. As a matter of fact, they update on Monday, Wednesday, and Friday. It’s very easy to keep up with, which in its own way is great.

XL Girls does updates roughly three to four times a week. Some of the content is fresh while others are just remastered videos and photos from the past. If we are just looking at fresh content, the site has updates at nearly the same frequency as Plumper Pass. So I hate to say it, but …

Advantage: Draw

Consensus: Join both, Plumper Pass if you’re frugal

There isn’t a true consensus, and we mentioned it in the introduction. While these are the two best BBW sites by a mile, they focus on two very different things. Plumper Pass wants to provide the best hardcore action and fapping material possible. XL Girls wants to introduce new girls and give viewers a variety of content to look at.

In many respects, you cannot get the full spectrum of BBW porn without looking at both sites. Both sites only show us one side of the coin. Not being able to make a choice isn’t a cop-out. Rather, it’s acknowledgement of how great both sites really are.

In the end, either join both sites, lean toward the kind of porn you’re more interested in, or just join Plumper Pass because it’s cheaper (as long as XL Girls isn’t doing a major discount). If you want an overdose of fat girls with huge tits and big asses getting nailed, join Plumper Pass. If you want a softer touch and a little more variety, join XL Girls.

4 thoughts on “BBW Porn Battle: Plumper Pass vs. XL Girls

  1. XL girls is laughable in regards to BBW, if anything they 9/10 are shooting plumpers or big naturals – NOT the same as BBW. And almost always white. They shoot and recycle same male talent and it’s old. Plumperpass went downhill over the years especially after he burned his bridges with big name BBW pornstars like sam , mazzaratie and Karla lane + countless other not so big name models. Why else is shooting thin models? Eventually you run out of BBW, you can only burn so many bridges and do bad business for so many years because your ship starts to sink

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s